Section OneGuard rail or bollards?
Ask whether you are protecting a length or a spot.
Short answer: Use guard rail to protect a run: a walkway, a row of rack ends, a line of machines. Use bollards to protect a single point: a rack corner, an electrical panel, a door frame or a building column.
Quick answers- Guard rail: Continuous barrier. Stops a vehicle anywhere along its length and separates people from traffic.
- Bollard: Standalone post. Protects one object and leaves room to walk around or reach past it.
- Published rating: Handle-It guard rail is tested to withstand 10,000 lb at 4 mph.
A bollard leaves gaps on either side on purpose, so a technician can reach the panel behind it. That is its strength for equipment and its weakness for walkways. A vehicle can pass between two bollards. It cannot pass through a rail.
A note on this guideThis guide is written from published manufacturer data and my own experience quoting this equipment. It is general guidance and my opinion, not engineering advice. Confirm the rating for your exact model and application before you order.
Section TwoWhat each one is
Published construction for the lines we carry.
Short answer: Guard rail is 13 gauge formed steel rail between heavy columns. Bollards are steel posts from 1-3/4 to 8-5/8 in. in diameter.
Handle-It guard rail| Item | Published figure |
|---|
| Rail lengths | 2 ft to 10 ft sections |
| Rail height | Single high 18 in.; double high 43 in. |
| Rail steel | 13 gauge ASTM A1011, powder-coated safety yellow |
| Columns | 4.75 x 4.75 in. on 10 x 10 in. base plates |
| Impact rating | Tested to 10,000 lb at 4 mph |
| Removable sections | Lift-out adapters for tool-free removal |
| Gates | Self-closing pedestrian gate, 36 to 54 in. opening; double rail swing gate |
Bollards| Bollard | Diameter or size | Height | Note |
|---|
| MECO heavy duty round | 4-1/2 or 5-1/2 in. | 24, 36 or 42 in. | Round steel |
| MECO square | 5 x 5 in. | 24, 36 or 42 in. | Square tube |
| Handle-It round | 4 or 6 in. | 42 in. | Surface mount, 10 x 10 in. base plate, 3/4 in. holes |
| Vestil round steel | 1-3/4 to 8-5/8 in. | 24 to 72 in. | Widest range |
| Vestil pour-in-place | 4-1/2 to 6-5/8 in. | 25 to 72 in. | Set in concrete |
| Vestil removable | 5-9/16 in. | See listing | Lifts out for access |
| Vestil fold down | See listing | 33-1/2 to 35-1/2 in.; 5 in. collapsed | Folds flat |
| Vestil spring-loaded | 2-1/2 in. | 42 in. | Flexes and returns upright |
Bollard impact resistance depends on pipe diameter, wall thickness, fill, mounting and height. Those figures are not on every listing, so ask for them on the model you are considering.
Section ThreeRacking, equipment and walkways
The three jobs in the title, one at a time.
Short answer: Rack rows and walkways get rail. Rack corners, panels and door frames get bollards.
Row of rack end frames facing a cross aisle
Guard rail across the end of the row.
A single exposed rack corner at a turn
Bollard, or a rack and column protector at forklift strike height.
Pedestrian walkway beside a forklift aisle
Guard rail, double high, which puts the top rail at torso height, with a self-closing gate at crossings.
Electrical panel, control cabinet, gas line
Bollards. They stop the truck and leave room to open the door.
Dock door tracks and door frames
Bollards at each jamb.
Building columns
Bollards or column guards.
Line of machines or an in-plant office
Guard rail, with lift-out sections where equipment has to come through.
Access needed occasionally for a vehicle
Removable or fold-down bollards, or a lift-out rail section.
A chain is not a barrierA chain between posts marks a boundary but does not stop a vehicle. Use it to guide people, not to protect them from trucks.
Section FourReading an impact rating
The rating is a weight and a speed together.
Short answer: Impact energy rises with the square of speed. Doubling the speed roughly quadruples the energy.
The Handle-It rail is tested at 10,000 lb at 4 mph. That is a specific combination. A lighter truck at the same speed is inside it. The same truck going faster is not.
Worked example
A 10,000 lb loaded truck at 4 mph matches the test. The same truck at 8 mph is traveling twice as fast, so it carries about 2 x 2 = 4 times the energy of the test. A 5,000 lb truck at 8 mph has half the weight and four times the speed factor: 0.5 x 4 = about 2 times the test energy.
Match the barrier to your heaviest loaded truck at the speed it actually travels in that aisle. Slowing traffic near people and equipment does more than a heavier barrier.
- Setback. Leave a gap between the barrier and what it protects, so the barrier can deflect without touching the asset.
- Mounting. Deeper embedment in sound concrete resists impact better than a surface-mounted post of the same diameter. Confirm slab thickness and condition first.
- Not fall protection. An impact barrier is not a fall protection guardrail. OSHA 1910.29 sets that at 42 in. plus or minus 3 in., with a 200 lb top rail load. They are different products.
Section FiveCost and layout
How the two compare when you are covering distance.
Short answer: Bollards cost less for a few points. Guard rail costs less per foot of protection once you are covering a run.
To protect one panel you need two or three bollards. To protect 40 ft of walkway with bollards close enough to stop a truck you would need a great many, and people could still be reached between them. Rail does that job with four 10 ft sections and five columns.
Measuring for rail
Rails run from 2 to 10 ft and column spacing follows the rail length, center to center. Add 1 in. to the overall dimension for lift-out or down guard adapters, and 1-1/2 in. when a gate joins a run. Use the 45 degree angle adapter to follow a wall or machine without custom fabrication.
Aisles also need marking. OSHA 1910.176(a) requires permanent aisles to be appropriately marked. See floor marking tape vs. paint.
Section SixCommon mistakes
What goes wrong after installation.
Short answer: The usual errors are bollards where rail was needed and barriers mounted tight against what they protect.
- Bollards along a walkway. People can be reached between posts.
- No setback. A barrier needs room to deflect.
- Surface mounting on a thin or cracked slab. The anchors and the slab carry the load.
- Leaving an opening for the occasional pallet. Use lift-out sections instead of leaving a gap.
- Reading 10,000 lb as a weight limit alone. The rating is a weight at a speed.
More in our barriers and machine guarding guide.
Section SevenFrequently asked questions
The questions I hear most on quote calls.
What is the difference between guard rail and bollards?
Guard rail is a continuous barrier that protects a run, such as a walkway or a row of rack ends. A bollard is a standalone post that protects a single point, such as a panel, a door frame or a column.
Should I use guard rail or bollards to protect pallet racking?
Use guard rail across a row of rack end frames. Use a bollard or a rack protector for a single exposed corner.
What protects a pedestrian walkway best?
Guard rail. A vehicle can pass between two bollards but not through a rail. Double high rail puts the top rail at torso height.
How strong is Handle-It guard rail?
It is tested to withstand 10,000 lb at 4 mph. The rail is 13 gauge ASTM A1011 steel on 4.75 x 4.75 in. columns with 10 x 10 in. base plates.
What size bollard do I need?
It depends on the vehicle and speed. The bollards we list run from 1-3/4 to 8-5/8 in. in diameter and 24 to 72 in. high. Ask for wall thickness and mounting details on the model you choose.
Does a higher speed really matter that much?
Yes. Impact energy rises with the square of speed, so doubling the speed roughly quadruples the energy the barrier has to absorb.